WWhodunnitCLUB

How to play

Every case is a closed puzzle, written in full before anything else: the killer, the timeline, every suspect's secrets and the clues that expose them. Nothing is improvised and nothing is random, so every case can be solved by logic alone.

Start with the first case

The Lodging House, at the top of the library, takes two minutes: two suspects, three rooms and a guide beside you that ticks off each move as you make it. It isn't scored, so play it as often as you like before the real cases.

Question the suspects

Each suspect gives you a first statement. Then ask them anything, in your own words: where they were, what they thought of the victim, who they suspect, what they are afraid of. Typos and chat-speak are fine, and two or three suggested questions are always there if you are stuck. Most suspects are hiding something, and most of their secrets are not murder.

Present evidence, and watch their composure

Nobody cracks because you asked twice. When you find the piece of evidence that contradicts someone's story, show it to them. What they admit becomes testimony, which you can show to someone else. Beside every suspect is a composure bar: it empties as the evidence lands, and when it crosses a line, from composed to rattled, to cracking, to broken, a stage direction tells you so. Evidence that means nothing to them lets them steady themselves, so show the right thing to the right person.

Let the notebook pay attention

The Notebook flags every claim a suspect made that clashes with evidence you hold, naming the piece that contradicts it, with the confrontation ready to use. It records the stories that have cracked and lists the claims nobody has tested, and it never names anything you haven't found. Stuck? Nudge me points at something you already have, for free; Give me a hint says what to do next, for 5% of your score.

Search, build the timeline, pin the board

Search each location for clues. The timeline fills in as you go; hollow markers are claims you have reason to doubt, and stretches with nothing recorded are marked as gaps. On the Board, pin clues to suspects under motive, means and opportunity, run a thread between the ones that belong together, and put the undated pieces in your own order. Nothing there is marked: it's your reasoning, saved with the game.

Each level plays differently

Harder cases don't just have more suspects. They ask more of you.

Three cases are free with an account, one at each of the first three levels, so you can try them all before you join.

Against the clock, or at leisure

In timed mode every question and search spends story time, and when the police arrive you must accuse. At your leisure, there is no deadline.

After the verdict

The story of how it happened plays out a paragraph at a time. Then you see which key clues you found and which you missed, your score, anything the case earned you, a page of the season's dossier, and a card to share that names nothing: the case, the result, your time and a row of squares.

Ranks, achievements and seasons

Points (your best score on each case, added up) and cases solved earn ranks from Constable to Commissioner. Achievements mark how you played: without a hint, within par, every lie caught, every clue found, a suspect broken. Every case belongs to a season, and underneath each season runs a dossier on a figure who is never a suspect; solving a case opens a page, solving them all opens the season's finale, where the figure can at last be accused. All of it is in your record.

The accusation and your score

Name the culprit, the motive, the method and the time, with your proof: on easy cases your strongest pieces of evidence, on harder ones the evidence behind each claim (proof only counts for a claim you got right). Accuracy is out of 100, then multiplied by difficulty (easy ×1, medium ×2, hard ×3, expert ×4). Finishing within the case's par time adds up to 20%. Each hint takes off 5%. Guessing at connections or lies costs a little after the first three wrong tries. A second attempt scores half, and later ones a quarter.

Choose a case